G u i d e   T o  L i b r a r y  R e s e a r c h
M H J H   M e d i a   C e n t e r

 

6.  Evaluating Resources - web sites
 

Things to consider:
  • authority
  • purpose or intended audience
  • current
  • objectivity v. bias
  • support

 
Authority
  • Who wrote the page?
  • What are the author's credentials?
  • Can you verify the author's credentials?  Could they be made up?
  • Did the author include contact information?
  • Whose web site is this?  What organization is sponsoring the web page?
  • Is there an "about this site" link?

Look for a tilde (~) in the URL.  This is used to identify a personal directory.  Be very careful.

 
Purpose or intended audience
  • What is the purpose of the page?   Advertise, news, entertainment, opinion satire, advocacy?
  • Why did the author create it?
  • Who is the target audience? Researchers, kids, buyers?
  • What is the reading level?  Is there lots of text?
  • Are there banner ads and animations?
 
Current
  • Is the page dated?  Current date doesn't always mean current information.
  • Is the information up-to-date?  Compare information of similar websites.
Objectivity vs. bias
  • Is the author objective or biased? Look for fair and balanced. 
  • Are facts clearly distinguished from the opinions? 
  • Are the facts accurate and complete?
Support
  • Does the author support the information?  Are there links or citations?  Does it include a bibliography?
  • Is the support respectable? Is there a variety of resources?  Are they well-known?
  • Is it hard for you to check the resources?
  Back to Evaluating Resources - Print
  
Before You Start Stepping into Research Choosing a
Topic
Background
Information
Refining a
Topic
Types of
Resources
Searching for
Information
Evaluating
Sources
Plagiarism & Documentation Citing Print Sources Citing Non-Print Sources Citing Electronic Sources Bib/Source Card Tips & Abbreviations Tips & Formatting
Stamping an Image               Copyright Sources               Sample of a Works Cited Page